Ranking 10 Best Football Pundits in the World Right Now

Football pundits have become a core part of the modern game, helping fans understand and engage with football for the entire match and even after it. Many former players, former managers and reputed journalists have worked their way up the ranks and are now a core part of the football punditry community.

Origin, evolution and significance of the football pundits

The origin of football punditry goes back to the early days of football, in which both the sport and broadcasting sources were gaining popularity. Many viewers were yet to understand the game, and football pundits were introduced to make things clear and entertaining for them. This was back in the 20th century when commentary led to the introduction of football pundits who offered analytic insights, pre- and post-match insights.

One of the earliest and famous pundits was Jimmy Hill, who was a core part of the BBC in the 1970s, during which he introduced the analytical and tactical breakdowns alongside match commentary. This set a certain benchmark for the football punditry community and made it more informative and tactical rather than just descriptive coverage.

Eventually, football earned more popularity in the 1990s and 2000s, and top leagues like the Premier League and La Liga signed broadcasting deals, which led to football punditry becoming a profession. Later, the rise of digital media, namely YouTube and other social media platforms, led to football pundits becoming more and more prominent.

Football pundits today are not just analysts or experts but cultural and entertaining figures as well. Their opinions have an influence to a great extent on many fans, whether it is on a transfer saga, a player, a team, or a specific match.

Nowadays, respected pundits, especially former iconic footballers turned pundits, often change the narrative on a specific team or a player through their opinions. However, the most significant role of football pundits is their educational influence and knowledge. They break down advanced tactical systems and make it simple for the fans using metrics like xG (expected goals), passing statistics, and many more.

Ranking Factors

There are a few ranking factors to keep in mind while listing the best 10 pundits. These are, namely:

• Analytical Depth: The ability to break down tactics and strategies.
• Entertainment Value: The ability to make discussions entertaining and lively rather than only making them analytical.
• Communication Skills: Basic communication skills to capture the attention of the audience and keep them engaged.
• Credibility: Having a credible background in football or journalism, which lends authority.

Here Are the 10 Best Football Pundits

10) Alan Shearer

The Premier League’s all-time top scorer has had a great transition from being one of the most prolific goal scorers to a football pundit in the BBC’s Match Of The Day Studio.

Alan Shearer was Gary Lineker’s right-hand man in football punditry and often avoids the critical style of football punditry, which Roy Keane does, and follows a much calmer approach. Shearer was a former captain of Newcastle United and England as well, which explains the leadership perspective that he brings into his commentary, speaking on decision making, mentality, and movements off the ball when analyzing attacking transitions and forwards.

9) Alex Scott

Alex has overcome a lot of barriers and prejudice in her media career, but she is one of the most accomplished football pundits, if not the most, right now. Alex Scott has earned an impressive 140 caps for England’s national team and has even won the quadruple with Arsenal only in the 2006-2007 season, which includes the FA Women’s Premier League, UEFA Women’s Cup, FA Women’s League Cup, and the FA Women’s Cup. She is one of the greatest football pundits.

Scott has a rather nonchalant behaviour when it comes to breaking down situations and offering insights without ever taking a shot at anyone, and her passion for football makes her presence very engaging.

The former Newcastle man has also engaged in other tournaments offering opinions and providing simple breakdowns for BBC’s coverage of major international tournaments namely the FIFA World Cup and UEFA tournaments. This signifies his ability to adapt and provide insights in a simple way for seasoned fans in both domestic as well as international tournaments.

ALSO READ: Top 10 Most Iconic Football Commentators

8) Peter Crouch

Peter Crouch truly spoils his fans in his downtime since he is the face of a few podcasts, is working simultaneously with a few big brands, as well as being a pundit. The 6 ft 7 in striker was a standout player, not mainly due to his height but his goalscoring prowess as well. He is surely one of the greatest football pundits.

Peter Crouch is an ever-present figure on TNT Sports and has a lot of stories to tell due to his experience playing with the likes of Gareth Bale, Bojan, and even Luis Suarez. He is reputed for his humor but has a great ability in insightful breakdowns as well.

7) Rio Ferdinand

Ferdinand has had an excellent career being a pivotal figure of one of the best teams in the history of football, namely the Manchester United team under Sir Alex Ferguson. That team got better and better, and it all paid off when they won the UEFA Champions League in 2008, beating Chelsea on penalties.

This helps him fit into the picture for UEFA Champions League coverage for TNT Sports, and his storytelling of what Sergio Busquets said on the pitch, what Sir Alex Ferguson used to say during key fixtures, and how he felt playing against Lionel Messi in the final makes it even more fitting. Furthermore, Rio Ferdinand was a ball-playing centre-back and one of the best defenders in the Premier League, which led to him being great at tactical breakdowns, and his screen analysis is simple and informative as well. He is surely one of the greatest football pundits.

6) Ian Wright

Today’s generation does not know the incredible journey of Ian Wright’s football career and how he was not even a footballer until his early 20s. Ian Wright went from his 9-5 job at DIY to scoring a staggering 185 goals at Arsenal.

Ian Wright is not great at tactical breakdowns, but is a great storyteller and knows a lot about scoring goals. Ian is a great pundit on Match Of The Day or ITV’s international coverage, and his emotional intelligence and storytelling make him relatable to a much broader audience as well. He is one of the greatest football pundits

5) Micah Richards

A wonderkid who never reached his heights and did decently at Fiorentina and Manchester City, but it is fair to say that Micah Richards is a better football pundit than he was as a player. He is surely one of the greatest football pundits.

His humorous personality and insights on his failure during his playing days make him the perfect blend for a football pundit, and Sky Sports and CBS are leaning on him. Micah’s enthusiasm for the game, alongside his jovial and informative style of journalism, makes him a great football pundit.

4) Roy Keane

Keane’s no-nonsense style of playing and ruthless demeanour have transferred to his punditry as well. Roy Keane was a ruthless player, often losing his temper at times, and would not hold back no matter the situation.

He is carrying that persona in his football punditry career as well, since he is often the centre of controversial opinions. Keane has never held back and always speaks out his opinion and has criticized quite a few players, teams, and management on air and once even had an argument with Jurgen Klopp.

Roy Keane’s most famous critical opinion has been regarding rival teams sharing a moment of truce, namely, Manchester United and Manchester City players, and Liverpool and Manchester United players.

This has incited mixed opinions amongst fans, with some agreeing with Roy Keane and some disagreeing with him. Nonetheless, a figure like Roy Keane is always needed in journalism since he has the guts and bravado to speak out on any situation, no matter how controversial it is. He is surely one of the greatest football pundits

3) Thierry Henry

The greatest Premier League player ever just has to be good at everything. Thierry Henry used to take on defenders in his prime and make light work of them, and the fact that he has stood out at Arsenal and FC Barcelona just makes it even better.

Henry is one of the legends of the game and is also Arsenal’s all-time top scorer, as well as his tactical knowledge and experience as one of the elite players at such elite clubs made him a great football pundit as well. Thierry Henry is a fan favourite in CBS’s famous team of pundits, namely Kate Abdo, Jamie Carragher, and Micah Richards.

Henry has often given tips on shooting for Erling Haaland and even broken down Kylian Mbappe’s signature finish. Thierry Henry’s credibility as one of the best strikers in Premier League makes his tactical analysis very apt and he breaks down the most complex movements and goals to make it very simple for the fans.

ALSO READ: Top 10 Best Soccer Celebrations: Iconic Moves & Gestures!

2) Jamie Carragher

Another player who was not as good or iconic as his teammates, but is an iconic pundit. In his playing days, Jamie Carragher was never quick, technically sound, or physically gifted, but was a very intelligent player.

It was a bit obvious that Carragher would delve into this field after his playing days ended. Although Jamie Carragher was never the first pick in England’s squad or was not a stand-out player, the fact that he has played with quite a few legendary players and won some iconic trophies only lends him a lot of authority.

Jamie Carragher’s duo with Gary Neville as football pundits blends very well, and the two are very entertaining and informative despite being former rivals, having played for Liverpool and Manchester United respectively.

1) Gary Neville

One of the underrated players in a star-studded Manchester United side during the Sir Alex Ferguson era. Gary Neville has become a key part of Sky Sports ” Monday Night Football”. Neville has been a part of many heated debates and iconic football moments. Some of his best moments include the scream when Fernando Torres scored the winning goal against FC Barcelona in the UEFA Champions League quarter-finals, his opinion on the Super League, and the self-critical takes on his managerial stint at Valencia.

ITV secured Gary Neville for international coverage, and Gary Neville has become a go-to voice for criticism on Manchester United and the big six teams in the Premier League as well. Although he was good as a player but he is one of the legendary football pundits.

List Of Top 10 Football Pundits In The World Right Now

Rank	Pundit
1	Gary Neville
2	Jamie Carragher
3	Thierry Henry
4	Roy Keane
5	Micah Richards
6	Ian Wright
7	Rio Ferdinand
8	Peter Crouch
9	Alex Scott
10	Alan Shearer

Bonus Section

BBC Football Pundits

The BBC Football Pundits have just recently added another iconic Manchester City player to their roster, and he is none other than Joe Hart. Joe Hart was not only known for his immense shot-stopping ability but his fierce nature and leadership on the pitch.

Joe Hart might just be one of quite a few goalkeepers turned football pundits, and that offers a fresh and new perspective. His ability to dissect and break down amazing saves, costly errors, decision-making under pressure, and defensive structures from a goalkeeper’s perspective has brought a new topic of interest for the BBC.

ITV Football Pundits

The ITV Football Pundits are also very famous around the world. Karen Carney, alongside Alex Scott, is potentially the best female football pundit out there. Karen has entered this field, which is usually dominated by men, and has surely made it her own.

Karen Carney has earned a staggering 140 caps for England’s national team during her career and has earned respect in ITV’s panel for her attention to detail. Karen has been a part of many men’s and women’s international tournaments and focuses on the smallest details in depth, whether it is team shape, pressing movements, off-the-ball movements, and much more.

Sky Sports Pundits

Jamie Redknapp has been a long-serving pundit for Sky Sports and is a credible figure in this industry. The former Liverpool and England midfielder has a calm and collected style as opposed to his fellow pundits, who have a much fiercer and critical nature.

Jamie Redknapp often does well when it comes to breaking down midfield transitions and styles, focusing on controlling the tempo of the game, ball progression, and positioning. His calm approach and insightful style make him relatable to the audience, and one of Sky Sports appreciated pundits as well.

ALSO READ: The 10 Best Manchester United Players Of All Time | Ranked